The Ripple Effect: Analyzing the Impact of Major NFT Legal Disputes in 2024 on Digital Asset Governance

In 2024, NFTs saw a significant rise amid a turbulent cryptocurrency landscape, with a legal framework emerging from several high-stakes court cases. A pivotal Spanish case set important standards for copyright and fair use concerning NFTs derived from pre-existing artworks. Additionally, notable legal actions were taken against large fashion brands, and the creators behind CryptoZoo faced allegations of mismanagement of their project. A U.S. court ruled in favor of a complaint regarding a contract dispute in the NFT marketplace.

NFTs Win Groundbreaking Case in Spain Regarding Copyright Issues

In January 2024, the Barcelona Commercial Court No. 9 made a historic ruling in Spain regarding the intersection of NFTs and copyright law. The case involved the fashion giant Mango, which had purchased five pieces from Spanish artists between 1998 and 2008. Without seeking permission from the artists, Mango commissioned digital artists to create NFTs featuring these works. These pieces, however, were never placed on a blockchain; they were merely showcased in stores, on social media, and within the Decentraland platform. The court decisively dismissed the authors’ claims, determining that Mango did not infringe upon their moral rights, as the artworks had been publicly available with the artists’ consent long before. The court ruled that since the NFTs were viewed as transformative rather than mere copies, they did not breach the authors’ rights nor their reproduction rights. Evaluating the situation through a ‘fair use’ lens, the court concluded that Mango’s actions were permissible since the NFTs were solely for display purposes, lacking any commercial intent, and did not harm the authors’ reputation or market.

Dolce & Gabbana Faces Lawsuit for Allegedly Not Delivering Promised NFT Perks

Legal action has been initiated by Luke Brown against Dolce & Gabbana,

asserting that the prestigious luxury fashion brand has failed to meet its commitments to NFT holders and has taken advantage of both primary and secondary markets for these digital assets. The lawsuit details how the DGFamily initiative, a collaboration with UNXD, did not fulfill its promises, neglecting to deliver the anticipated benefits, which included everything from physical clothing items to virtual fashion pieces and access to exclusive events. Initially, the first digital wearables were only launched on the Decentraland Metaverse platform, arriving a month later than promised. This legal challenge comes on the heels of a $1.9 million settlement with Rob Gronkowski, a former NFL player, who had to pay out to support the now-defunct crypto lender Voyager Digital. As of now, Dolce & Gabbana has not posted anything regarding DGFamily across its social media since April 2023, and its NFTs are currently trading at a mere fraction of an ether on OpenSea.

The company has yet to respond to requests for comments. In other news, Pump.fun, a well-known trading platform for meme coins, celebrated its second-highest revenue day since launching last Thursday, although it was reportedly exploited for around $2 million.

CryptoZoo's Co-Founders Accused of Sabotaging the Project; Logan Paul Seeks Compensation

Accusations have surfaced that two co-founders of CryptoZoo have derailed the cryptocurrency venture by leveraging their fame to orchestrate a complicated NFT scam. Logan Paul is pursuing not just reimbursement for his expenses,

but also punitive and compensatory damages. The proposed buyback plan, laden with legal complexity and stringent time limits, does not indicate that Paul has acknowledged any legal responsibilities related to the widespread scamming within CryptoZoo. Participants who purchased base animal NFTs and basic egg NFTs must complete their claim forms by February 8, 2024, after which all claims will be settled. Eligible buyers may receive around $240 worth of 0.1 ETH for each qualifying NFT. The intended design of the game indicates that these hybrid animal NFTs are supposed to be non-refundable. Paul clarifies that this buyback initiative is not designed to compensate individuals who faced losses in the volatile cryptocurrency market but is aimed at making things right for those who intended to engage with CryptoZoo. California Court Greenlights Little Orbit's Lawsuit Against Ultimax Digital

The United States District Court for the Central District of California has denied Ultimax Digital Inc.'s motion to dismiss Little Orbit Inc.'s case, which alleges breach of contract, patent violations, and trade secret theft.

According to Little Orbit, in 2020, Ultimax had hired them to develop the video game 'Tantra Rumble,' which later was renamed 'StoneHold,' alongside creating a digital card NFT marketplace. The lawsuit was filed in October 2023 within the Central District of California.

The court rejected Ultimax’s request, highlighting that the case stems from Ultimax’s dealings in California, further affirming that the court was leveraging its right to conduct business within the state. The court established that Little Orbit's accusations regarding trade secret misappropriation against Ultimax were substantial enough to continue. As a result, the judge allowed the complete case against Ultimax to proceed in California. , please remember that the details shared on this page are not designed to be taken as legal, tax, investment, financial, or any other professional advice. It's crucial to invest only what you can afford to lose and consult independent financial advisors for any uncertainties. For more detailed information, we encourage you to review the terms and conditions along with the help and support resources provided by the issuer or advertiser. MetaversePost remains dedicated to delivering precise and impartial reporting, though market conditions may fluctuate without prior warning. Victoria writes on an array of technology topics, including Web 3.0, AI, and cryptocurrencies. Her extensive background enables her to create insightful articles for a diverse audience.

Blum Celebrates Its One-Year Anniversary With 'Best GameFi App' and 'Best Trading App' Titles at the 2025 Blockchain Forum